Judge Strikes Down Montana's Controversial Gender Law

Though judge didn't address the concerns of gender-nonconforming people who challenged it
By Gina Carey,  Newser Staff
Posted Dec 10, 2023 1:40 PM CST
Updated Jun 26, 2024 12:00 AM CDT
Indigenous 'Two-Spirit' People Challenge New Gender Law
File photo of a pride flag.   (AP Photo/George Walker IV, File)
UPDATE Jun 26, 2024 12:00 AM CDT

A controversial Montana law that defined sex as only male or female was on Tuesday struck down by a judge. The law had been challenged by plaintiffs who argued it denied legal recognition and protections to those who are gender-nonconforming, but District Court Judge Shane Vannatta did not address that argument. Rather, he ruled it violated the state constitution because the legislation's description fails to clearly state its purpose, the AP reports. "The title does not give general notice of the character of the legislation in a way that guards against deceptive or misleading titles," he wrote, noting that the title doesn't explain whether the word "sex" was used in reference to sexual intercourse or gender, and also fails to indicate that the words "female" and "male" would be defined in the bill's body.

Dec 10, 2023 1:40 PM CST

A new law in Montana that went into effect last month rigidly defines sex in ways that Indigenous Two-Spirit Native Americans say violate their religious and cultural rights. CNN breaks down how Senate Bill 458 affects that community, and how they're pushing back against it. A little background: Gov. Greg Gianforte signed the bill in May, legally defining sex as either male or female based on an individual's XX or XY chromosomes and reproductive organs, per the Montana Free Press. The ruling influences dozens of parts of state code, including driver's licenses, demographic records, and anti-discrimination laws. The Missoulian Two-Spirit Society has now joined a lawsuit challenging the law.

"We don't ascribe to just simply biologic definitions," says David Herrera, co-founder and executive director of the group. "We acknowledge that there are different genders, and our cultures have always known that there are more than two genders." The Missoulian explains that "Two-Spirit" is an umbrella term referring to Indigenous people who have both a masculine and a feminine spirit. Historically they were assigned spiritual roles in ceremonies and in healing practices, roles of great importance. Indigenous scholar Kalpana Jain writes in the Conversation that stories passed down by the Blackfeet "acknowledged and accepted individual gender expression and identity because it was granted by the divine. Personal gender identity was rarely questioned, because it was tantamount to questioning the divine."

story continues below

Herrera says Two-Spirit identities were seen as "an abomination" during colonization, and as tribes began assimilating, aggression toward LGBTQ people within Native communities grew. "We've already been traumatized through so many things that the government has done to us and so we just figured it's time—we have to step up and reclaim what's rightfully ours and not let the government take that away from us," Steven Barrios, a co-founder of the Montana Two-Spirit Society, tells CNN. Per Montana Public Radio, plaintiffs in the case also include two intersex individuals, who say the new definition on the books fails to recognize their chromosomal differences, and a transgender Navy veteran. The state is expected to answer the lawsuit by mid-December. (Navajo Nation is grappling with gay marriage ban.)

Get the news faster.
Tap to install our app.
X
Install the Newser News app
in two easy steps:
1. Tap in your navigation bar.
2. Tap to Add to Home Screen.

X